Vol.. 24 No. 3 Spring 2003

The Community College
CCHA HUMANIST

A Tri Annual Publication of the Community College Humanities Association

Poverty and the Power of Knowledge
By John D. Scolaro and Elizabeth Eschbach
Valencia Community College, Florida

Poverty in America , however defined, is one of the best kept secrets in town. This conclusion is discussed at length by Eal horris, founder of The Clemente Course in the Humanities at Valencia Community College , in his Riches for the Poor(1997-2000). In fact, Shorris says that poverty in America we think. He believes that most of us are self-insulated. The real conditions of poverty and homelessness remain obscure, thus the root causes of these life-conditions into which any of us may fall at any time should be unveiled and examined if we, as Americans, are truly interested in helping to resolve the modern plague of the human spirit. This is where education and knowledge as a source of power enter the door Shorris has courageously opened.

 In fact, in Orlando , Florida , where we have lived and worked for over a decade now, the Orlando Sentinel's January 10, 2002 issue reported that there are at least 6,500 homeless individuals living in Central Florida . This is a 10% increase over last year‑   at about the same time.  The real number of poor and homeless individuals, however, is actually higher if other independent and more dependable demographic sources, such as The Pew Center for the People and the Press are accessed.

Most Americans should know that the poor and homeless often experience, as Shorris contends, such a loss of dignity that they have been encased in what he calls 'the surround of force' and have been excluded from what the Greek Classical Period statesman, Pericles, called "the political life" or from what Veniece Walker, an inmate at a Bedford Hills maximum security prison for women in a Westchester suburb located 50 miles north of New York City, called "the moral life of downtown." In other words, forces such as hunger, isolation, illness, landlords, police, abuse, drugs, racism, neighbors, criminals, and agencies of government designed to assist the poor out of poverty actually enclose them in a "surround of force" which makes it virtually. impossible for those trapped by such experiences to extricate themselves. It is as if these marginalized citizens of our community are condemned to poverty forever. Shorris believes that those immersed in the abyss of poverty have been excluded from the moral alternative to the street, such as the theater, museums, concerts, and lectures. He claims that the humanities is the way out of this conundrum because it is driven by the truth of knowledge as a source of real power and nurtures reflective rather than reactive thinking.

What is important, however, is the role and function a humanities education in its more unconventional form might play in helping poor and homeless individuals find their own way out of poverty. This is why The Clemente Course in the Humanities might serve as a way out for many individuals trapped by "the surround of force."

Part I of The Clemente Course in the Humanities on Moral Philosophy and Literature concluded on November 20, 2002. Students enrolled in the course met for a period of 8 weeks every Wednesday evening from 7 p.m. 9 p.m. at two locations in the downtown Orlando area: The Women's Residential and Counselina Center (VVT CC) on East Colonial Drive and The Wells'Built Museum of African American History and Culture in Parramore. The class at the WRCC, a temporary shelter for women, included a total of 8 students; The Wells'Built course had a class of 12 men from the The Wayne Densch Center for Preferred Living, a temporary shelter for men, including three students from The Ripple Effect, a local non profit organization serving the needs of homeless individuals in Orlando.

In order to enroll in the course, students were asked to write a one to two page application letter in which they expressed their interest in the humanities, discussed a book or story they had read which had a significant impact on their life, and explained what they hoped to get out of The Clemente Course. Two professors of humanities were invited to teach the courses as part of their contract load. Their competence and pedagogical style were exceptional. They are the true architects of this unique experiment in education for the multi generational poor. Their work with the students enrolled in these first two Clemente Course classes was guided by the following Outcomes:

Outcomes:

  • To nurture in students, as a result of the pedagogy of dialogue based on the siciplines of Moral Philosophy and Literature via use of the Socratic Method, a discovery or rediscovery of one's unlimited potential,

  • To move students from reactive to reflective thinking based on their understanding of the great ideas of philosophy, art, literature, history, and logic,

  • To instill in students the advantages of negotiation over the use of force,

  • To demonstrate among students the psychological benefits of working within a group as well as the importance of mutual respect between them and their professor,

  • To emphasize the importance of family involvement in the form of more effective parenting as well as the values of reflective thinking and self dignity as a method of transcending the cycle of multi generational poverty,

  • To demonstrate Valencia 's responsibility for building an inclusive learning community which extends beyond the boundaries of our classrooms and campuses to the community we serve,

  • To equip those individuals encased in what Earl Shorris calls 'the surround of force' with the requisite knowledge of the radical nature of the humanities so as to recover one's self dignity based on the view of the nature of knowledge and its pursuit as a source of power,

  • To expose students to the 'moral life of downtown' both within and outside of the classroom context (e.g., theater, museums, concerts, lectures, etc.) as the 'door' to the recovery of what Pericles called 'the political life' in the form of greater participation as citizens within the context of one's family, neighborhood, city, state, and nation

  • To build respect for diversity as a method of increasing the opportunity for all to participate in the prosperity we seek. Upon successful completion of The Clemente Course in the Humanities course requirements, the students were awarded a Certificate of Completion from Valencia during a formal ceremony hosted by the president of the college. Students experienced an increased level of motivation as a result of the successful completion of the course and its requirements, to pursue a college level, credit course of study at Valencia or at any other institution of higher education or to secure gainful employment.

As Sanford C. Shugart, president of Valencia Community College and avid supporter of The Clemente Course in the Humanities, said, "I am intrigued that learning can be liberating. It empowers people with knowledge to make their way through the system. Sometimes people are trapped." This sentiment was echoed by a first time Clemente Course student who said: "The most valuable thing I learned in the course is that you can overcome." What more effective outcome can we seek as teaching professionals than to know that one of our students learned something of value in our class? After all, knowledge is power.

John D. Scolaro and Elizabeth Eschbach are professors of humanities at Valencia Community College in Orlando, Florida. John is the Project Director of The Clemente Course in the Humanities and Elizabeth is a Clemente Course professor at The Women's Residential and Counseling Center (WRCC. See http://valenciacc.edu/clemente for more about The Clemente Course in the Humanities.

 

               

 

Return to Reference Links

The Prometheus Project Home Page